A
few years ago, I wrote this
article about this infamous "quote" from Shakespeare:
"I
always feel happy. You know why? Because I don't expect anything from
anyone; expectations always hurt. Life is short, so love your life.
Be happy and keep smiling. Just live for yourself and always
remember: Before you speak... Listen. Before you write... Think.
Before you spend... Earn. Before you pray... Forgive. Before you
hurt... Feel. Before you hate... Love. Before you quit... Try. Before
you die... Live."
At
the time I debunked it as NOT-Shakespeare but left it at that. But a
few days later I came across it on Reddit...I had to unearth the
notebook in which I had written down a similar poem by William Arthur
Ward which goes:
"Before you speak, listen.
Before you write, think.
Before you spend, earn.
Before you invest, investigate.
Before you criticize, wait.
Before you pray, forgive.
Before you quit, try.
Before you retire, save.
Before you die, give."
I
had noted it down for future reference and also in order to track its
source. I had never taken the time to do this, so today I did.
NO-EFFING-WHERE! Zilch, nada, rien, nought. Couldn't find the
original source for the poem to save my life. Does anyone know?
That's a question for Quora, since Reddit people took the bait.
Not
quite the same poem. Lines 3 and 4 are missing from the Shax ref. Two
lines are inserted in the Shax ref after "pray, forgive".
Penultimate line is skipped, last line is altered (give/live). The
Ward poem (I'll call it that for the time being) definitely has
rhyming patterns: listen/earn; investigate/wait;
forgive/give (even save). We do hear echoes in
the pairs: speak/think; invest/investigate;
wait, pray, save. I'm not a Ward specialist, but
that's arguably a better disposition, phrasing, tone, structure, than
the Shakesparean "equivalent". Less schmaltz, more
pragmatically inspirational.
Ironically
enough, when you google "William Arthur Ward", one first
look won't yield the quote: you need a second, more careful look to
find it. Not exactly buried, yet not in plain sight. My guts tell me
we haven't seen the last of this affair [insert smiley of your
choosing].
All
in all, I'm still amazed that this quote still roams the outskirts of
the Internet.
Edit:
I published this post, and then had an epiphany and found this
Snopes article, for all intents and purposes.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Avis sur la chose en question
Feedback on the thing in question